A Fresh Retelling of a Timeless Classic

Little Women is a joint production between PBS and the BBC to turn Louisa May Alcott’s classic novel into a three-episode television miniseries. The journey of the March sisters through adolescence has appeared on movie screens in 1994 (Winona Ryder and Susan Sarandon), 1949 (June Allyson and Elizabeth Taylor), and 1933 (Katharine Hepburn). The three-part miniseries uses the extended time wisely to bring out the stories of all of the sisters, not just the oldest sibling Jo (Maya Hawke). In keeping with the original novel, each episode is a string of vignettes that form an overall picture of the transformation from childhood to maturity.

After seeing so many negative reviews and fan comments on Twitter immediately after the premiere based solely on elitism, ageism, and nostalgia, there is a need to defend this adaptation of Little Women. Many critics and viewers are going beyond legitimate arguments about style, acting, and technical factors and are going straight for gatekeeping and the shaming of younger fans who love this miniseries. These arguments are lost on an entire generation of children and young adults who have never seen the previous movie adaptations. It is safe to say there may be girls watching this miniseries before they even read Alcott’s original. Modernity is not an inherently bad thing. Little Women is attempting to appeal to younger fans who love historical dramas. This is a chance for a whole new generation to enjoy the March sisters.

Related | Victoria Series 2 Final Verdict

[wp_ad_camp_2]

Girl Power In Front Of & Behind The Camera

Millennials are leading the way in discussions of female representation in popular culture. Although period dramas may not be the best platform for intersectional feminism, Little Women as a production brings multiple generations of women from both sides of the Atlantic together to spotlight the feelings of Civil War era teenagers. Jo March, Amy March (Kathryn Newton), Meg March (Willa Fitzgerald) and Beth March (Annes Elwy) are the heart of the story. These newcomers are keeping the audience invested, despite most people’s prior knowledge of the story. Aunt March (Angela Lansbury) and Marmee (Emily Watson) bring a one-two punch of gravitas as the elder stateswomen of the story.

“I think it was amazing to get to be looking at the lives and the growth of these women through the lens of a female perspective, which is something that, you know, oftentimes isn’t the case. And I think my favorite moment was the email that I received before we got to Ireland, asking me to not shave for the next three weeks and through the production period. Which I think is like, a uniquely, a unique request and one that would’ve only happened under female direction, because there was a desire to show femininity and womanhood in all of its forms.”- Willa Fitzgerald

It is highly appropriate that one of the first novels by an American woman about the experiences of teenage girls and women has a female showrunner for its 2018 television adaptation. Heidi Thomas is an expert at telling the stories of real women. Her work on Call the Midwife on PBS and BBC earn considerable praise from TV critics and feminists on both sides of the Atlantic for spotlighting the lives of working-class women in 1960’s London. Thomas, at the TriBeCa Film Festival, mentioned that female inclusivity is the “milieu” she is used to working in. Director Vanessa Caswill brings Thomas’ script to life by using close-ups on the March sisters and their environment as another character in the story. All of these factors combined result in a production that is completely friendly to the Millennial point of view on pop culture.

[wp_ad_camp_2]

The March sisters have relatable personalities and struggles

The joys and the sorrows of the sisterly bond haven’t changed from the novels. The dialogue between the sisters has elements of 1860’s slang combined with raw honesty which ensures the spirit of the book survives, despite the necessary cuts for time. Readers in every generation have seen their personalities in at least one March sister. Hawke captures Jo’s tenacity. Fitzgerald effortlessly portrays Meg’s calmness. Newton is a master at showing Amy’s self-interested ways. Elwy convinces us she is as shy as Beth. Those traits are timeless. The key to this adaptation is Thomas’s added nuance with the benefit of hindsight, and her knowledge of each March sister previously removed from abridged editions of the novels.

Jo as an aspiring writer at a time when women were expected only to become wives and mothers. She pushes back the hardest against social pressure and the patriarchy She defends her literary pursuits from detractors. She even wishes she was born a boy because there are no limits on education or other pursuits. Her struggle against the patriarchy is a rallying cry to today’s Millennials and Generation Z. Hawke commands attention every time Jo’s temper flares. Her journey to adulthood is the central focus of the novel, but Thomas ensures her siblings also get their fair share of screen time.

Beth’s story overall benefits the most from modernization. She is more than a shy girl. Heidi Thomas, at the TriBeCa Film Festival premiere, explained that she interpreted Beth as a girl with generalized anxiety disorder. At the time Alcott wrote, psychology as a field of study was in its infancy. Elwy brings this out every time Beth stares with fear at the gate leading to Mr. Lawrence’s (Michael Gambon) house. She forces the audience to confront their ableist biases. Later on, Beth faces the fact her health will not improve in a way a modern chronic illness patient would. Although Thomas may not have intended to raise awareness on this issue, the show still connects with the thousands of young women facing mortality due to a wide variety of physical ailments and mental health struggles.

Meg is usually the girl to go with the flow — that is until Aunt March strongly dissents to her engagement to John (Julian Morris). It is then that she finds the strength to stand up for her love. This scene is relatable For anyone who has had to stand up to bigoted or old-fashioned relatives, even in today’s modern society. Jo pushes back against the patriarchy and girls today have that same fight in similar forms.

Kathryn Newton’s delivery of Amy’s often sly remarks results in a partial rehabilitation of the bad impression many people have of Amy in the novel. Amy is keenly aware that she has upset her sisters with her jealousy. In some ways, Amy may actually be the quintessential stereotype of a Millennial, which is what makes her character so entertaining to watch. Amy’s redemption arc in Episode 3 reminds us that there is always a second chance.

[wp_ad_camp_2]

Iconic moments from the novel stir the memories of viewers

There is a common misconception that Millennials always want to burn history down to the ground. Millennials may have new ways of approaching historical narratives, but there is no doubt that they are watching PBS programs because they appreciate history and classic literature. Many young women remember reading Alcott’s novel as children. Some fans on social media even said their mothers read it to them. Even younger viewers who have seen the previous movies are looking for hallmark moments in the story. The key to the success of Little Women is how the cast and crew breathe new life into these iconic scenes.

I must watch. Little Women was the first book I got caught staying up all night reading. My mom saw what I was reading and kissed me on the forehead and told me to carry on. She loved it, too. #littlewomenpbs https://t.co/9IbEx0jxs1

— danielle paige (@daniellempaige) May 21, 2018

Episode 1 dives right in with Amy spitefully burning Jo’s manuscript in retaliation for not being invited to the theater. This scene was already a powerful scene in the book, but Thomas takes this to the next level by having Jo slap Amy in retribution. Many people don’t realize this, but “box your ears” is 1860’s slang for a slap. The ice pond accident and the bullying over the pickled limes are crucial moments for Amy’s realizing the darker side of her decisions. Beth’s declining health in Episodes 2 and 3 makes viewers cry in the same way the novels did. Jo refusing Laurie (Jonah Hauer-King) has a new urgency in the days where men are angered by the “friend zone”. These large touchstone moments are what define Little Women, and none of them have been significantly altered.

Little Women is often the gateway drug to tracking relationships in fiction, and this miniseries gives ‘shippers the joy and the heartbreak they love so much from the novels. For many women, Laurie is their first literary crush, and the feelings from the books come back with a vengeance. The Jo/Laurie “comfortable friend” dynamic is believable because of Hawke and Hauer-King’s‘ chemistry. Professor Bhaer (Mark Stanley) is older than Jo but you can see in a much clearer way why she would fall for him. He supports her writing and treats her as an intellectual equal. Bhaer could easily be a hipster creative writing professor at The New School riding the L train. Despite having disjointed screen time in Episode 3, Amy and Laurie’s relationship confirms why Alcott broke up Jo and Laurie. There’s very subtle foreshadowing starting with the ice pond in Episode 1 which makes Amy’s eventual elopement with Laurie make sense for viewers who are less familiar with the story.

[wp_ad_camp_2]

Marmee forces the conversation on women’s anger

Another common misconception many have is that younger women can’t relate to older women. Marmee is beloved across the generations. In fact, there is one specific scene in Episode 1 that seals the deal. After Jo rages about Amy burning the manuscript, Marmee tells Jo the truth about her emotions. Marmee has suppressed her anger and frustrations for 40 years for the sake of being a polite member of society. The battle between women’s emotions and what society expects has not changed between 1862 and today.

I think Marmee’s layers and her complexity are completely overlooked by the juvenile reader…if you underestimate Marmee or don’t treat her with enough attention to detail or enough respect, you lose a lot of the ballast and a lot of the texture of the novel, so I think not approaching Marmee from the right angle is a real mistake and has perhaps caused problems of the book’s image over the years.” – Heidi Thomas

Society constantly tells women that it is not nice to show anger. Men call women hysterical or overdramatic in situations when women are genuinely offended or angered by the actions of others. Especially in Alcott’s day, a woman like Marmee trying to assert any sort of power would result in anger because society at the time considered women ill-suited for public life or making their own decisions. Men especially believe women are “hysterical or overreacting in instances where a woman was offended by the actions of others. Although there are moments in the modern world when expressing anger isn’t ideal, it was even more of a problem back when married women like Marmee were essentially the property of their husbands. Fans who have seen other adaptations of Little Women have noted on Twitter this moment is not featured. It is a safe bet this scene doesn’t jibe with the overall vision of Marmee’s wholesome nature from the novels. Overall, it says so much about how people today are questioning how society has assigned gender roles to emotions every human has.

[wp_ad_camp_2]

Related | Timeless Season 2 Four Episode Challenge

Show Little Women to the next generation of period drama fans

Every current period drama fan can easily name the series that got them hooked on the genre. This adaptation of Little Women hasn’t won everyone who loved the book as a kid over. However, this adaptation is an excellent gateway for your children, younger relatives, and students. This is the first truly under 18-friendly production Masterpiece has aired in several years, so take full advantage of this opportunity. Set aside your personal preferences for earlier adaptations and your favorite Millennial will definitely appreciate it.

Little Women can be streamed on PBS Passport or on Amazon Prime’s Masterpiece Channel.

Approach the older Little Women movies with an open mind

Then come back to TVAfterDark in July for coverage and live tweets of Harlots Season 2 and the long-awaited Poldark Season 4!

What's your reaction?

LOL

Cheers

What!?

Meh...

100%

Sad

RAGE!

About the Author

Amanda Prescott

Amanda-Rae Prescott turned blogging and tweeting about her favorite television shows into a Master’s Degree from the Columbia Journalism School and a career in social media management. When she isn’t bingeing period dramas or Doctor Who, she’s cosplaying her favorite characters at comic conventions. Current favorite TV shows include Victoria, Poldark, Doctor Who, Outlander, The Crown, Call the Midwife, and The Marvellous Mrs. Maisel. Her goal in blogging is to encourage more fan engagement and diversity of voices in period drama and historical costuming. She is also a contributor to Blacklanderz and the founder of the Poldark Costuming Project, a blog devoted to analyzing and researching late 18th Century clothing.

The Shadowhunters fandom is raising their voices in the right way

by Ana Martinez on June 22, 2018

Shadowhunters’ fans raise over $14,000 for the Trevor Project as part of their #SaveShadowhunters campaign The Shadowhunters fans keep proving they are a force to be reckoned with. Ever since the news broke that the series had been canceled by [...]

Why it’s important to save Shadowhunters

by Ana Martinez on June 9, 2018

There are some shows that come and go. Shadowhunters shouldn’t be one of them As we all know by now, Shadowhunters was recently canceled by Freeform. The surprising announcement came Monday night when it was revealed that Season 3 would be the show’s last [...]

Let’s Rewind: A Heartfelt Thank You to The Fosters

by Sophia Myers on June 8, 2018

The Fosters is a show that hits home for so many of us. The 3-day series finale of Freeform’s groundbreaking drama just aired, and we have a lot of feelings about it. We’re going to miss the tears, the laughs, and most importantly, that feeling of knowing [...]

comments

Little Women is an Aggressively Millennial Period Drama

A Fresh Retelling of a Timeless Classic

Related | Victoria Series 2 Final Verdict

Girl Power In Front Of & Behind The Camera

The March sisters have relatable personalities and struggles

Iconic moments from the novel stir the memories of viewers

Marmee forces the conversation on women’s anger

Related | Timeless Season 2 Four Episode Challenge

Show Little Women to the next generation of period drama fans

Little Women can be streamed on PBS Passport or on Amazon Prime’s Masterpiece Channel.

Approach the older Little Women movies with an open mind

The Shadowhunters fandom is raising their voices in the right way

Why it’s important to save Shadowhunters

Let’s Rewind: A Heartfelt Thank You to The Fosters